login
Hints
(Greetings from The On-Line Encyclopedia of Bongard Problems!)

Keywords in the OEBP

Here are some properties of Bongard Problems that we have decided are interesting enough to distinguish with an easy-to-search label.
To see all the Bongard Problems with (for example) keyword nice, type keyword:nice into the search bar.

Since this is a website based on showing properties of things in Bongard Problems, each keyword is actually a meta Bongard Problem (a Bongard Problem sorting Bongard Problems). To add a keyword to a Bongard Problem, add the Bongard Problem to the appropriate side of the Bongard Problem for that keyword.
There is also a "KEYWORDS" section in the Bongard Problem submission form, in which you can enter the names of keywords, that makes this process more convenient.
Table of keywords
Keyword Description Meta BP number
easyEasy for people to solve.BP501left
hardHard for people to solve.BP501right
nice"NP" (Nice Problem!)BP503left
lessMore Bongard Problems like this should not be added to the database. It may be interesting as a one-off example or is kept for historical reasons.BP503right
stubMore examples are needed. Please add to this Bongard Problem.BP504left
preciseA Bongard Problem with an exact definition. For all possible examples, it is clear which go left, which go right, and which are uncategorized.BP508left
fuzzyA Bongard Problem with an inexact definition.BP508right
allsortedA Bongard Problem that sorts all possible relevant examples. There are no uncategorized cases.BP509left
abstractThe solution is not a literal geometrical or numerical property in examples.BP512left
noisyThere are extraneous details shown changing between examples that distract from the solution.BP511left
minimalThe only details shown changing between examples are those necessary to communicate the solution.BP511right
convolutedA Bongard Problem with convoluted solution involving clauses connected by "OR"s or elaborate rules in the description. These Bongard Problems would usually also be tagged with the keyword "less."BP549right
unwordableThe solution is hard to put into words concisely. (This does not necessarily mean that the solution is hard to see.)BP506left
notsoA Bongard Problem with solution naturally expressed as "[fits rule] vs. not so."BP867left
teachA Bongard Problem whose examples might be used to teach a person or computer to recognize the pattern.BP858left
spectrumA Bongard Problem involving a less-than/greater-than quantity comparison.BP507left
dualA Bongard Problem in which there is a natural one-to-one correspondence between left examples and right examples; there is some clear way to transform an example that will flip its side.BP534left
arbitraryThe solution involves something arbitrary. Changing around this arbitrary detail gives way to many slightly different Bongard Problem with equally nice solutions.BP950left
handedA Bongard Problem in which orientation is relevant; flipping examples might affect their sorting.BP552left
leftrightA Bongard Problem in which left-right orientation is relevant; flipping examples over the vertical axis might affect their sorting.BP535left
updownA Bongard Problem in which up-down orientation is relevant; flipping examples over the horizontal axis might affect their sorting.BP1009left
rotateA Bongard Problem in which rotation is relevant; rotating examples might affect their sorting.BP553left
sizeA Bongard Problem in which absolute size is relevant; scaling examples might affect their sorting.BP554left
stretchA Bongard Problem in which stretching examples might affect their sorting.BP1112left
boundingboxA Bongard Problem in which expanding the bounding boxes of examples might affect their sorting.BP974left
blackwhiteA black and white Bongard Problem in which flipping the black and white pixels in examples might affect their sorting.BP556left
stableA Bongard Problem in which small changes to examples cannot affect their sorting.BP963right
unstableA Bongard Problem in which small changes to examples can affect their sorting.BP963left
numberThe solution only depends on counting the number of something.BP575right
mathThe solution is about mathematics.BP571left
physicsThe solution is related to physical phenomena.BP572left
3dA Bongard Problem about 3D objects such that the solution is unrelated to the particular 2D representation.BP1010right
projectionmattersA Bongard Problem about 3D objects such that the solution is related to the particular 2D representation.BP1010left
hardsortA Bongard Problem in which some examples might be hard to sort even after the solution is known.BP864right
antihumanA Bongard Problem that is hard for people to solve and easier for computers to solve.BP565left
anticomputerA Bongard Problem that is hard for computers to solve and easier for humans to solve.BP565right
subjectiveA Bongard Problem in which sorting examples is subjective.BP520left
cultureA Bongard Problem that involves culture-based information.BP521left
solvedSomebody has solved this hard Bongard Problem (without hints).BP826left
challengeNobody has solved this hard Bongard Problem (without hints).BP826right
metaA Bongard Problem whose examples are Bongard Problems.BP537left
linksA meta Bongard Problem whose examples are links to other pages on the OEBP.BP1126left
miniproblemsA meta Bongard Problem whose examples are miniature images of Bongard Problems.BP1126right
keywordA meta Bongard Problem corresponding to one of the keywords in this list.BP518left
oebpA Bongard Problem with solution related to the OEBP.BP1113left
exampleA Bongard Problem that was included on the OEBP primarily to be used as an example in other, meta Bongard Problems.BP1121left
worldA Bongard Problem such that one of its sides is commonly used as the pool of examples (the world) for other Bongard Problems on the OEBP.BP546left
conceptA Bongard Problem with solution "Related to [concept] vs. not so."BP814left
metaconceptA meta Bongard Problem listing Bongard Problems related to some specific concept.BP519left
primitiveA metaconcept Bongard Problem about a property primitive to visual cognition. (See Harry E. Foundalis's work.)BP577left
left-selfA meta Bongard Problem that is sorted on its own left side. This keyword is added to pages automatically.BP517left
right-selfA meta Bongard Problem that is sorted on its own right side. This keyword is added to pages automatically.BP517right
sideA meta Bongard Problem in which flipping the sides of Bongard Problems might affect their sorting.BP539left
sidelessA meta Bongard Problem in which any Bongard Problem and its flipped version are both sorted the same way.BP539right
invarianceA meta Bongard Problem about whether a certain transformation can affect examples' sorting.BP566left
creativeexamplesA Bongard Problem in which some examples fit the solution in varied creatively interesting ways.BP866left
presentationmattersA meta Bongard Problem that does not sort Bongard Problems based solely on their solutions.BP895left
metametaA Bongard Problem that sorts meta Bongard Problems.BP547left
metametametaA Bongard Problem that sorts meta meta Bongard Problems.BP1007left
overriddensolutionA solution idea that can never be communicated because a simpler solution will always override it.BP568left
gapA Bongard Problem in which the two sides are completely different classes of examples, with no clear choice of middle-ground in between.BP964right
distractingworldThe class of examples included is irrelevant to the solution idea.BP865left
animatedA Bongard Problem that uses animation in its examples.BP995left
colorA Bongard Problem that uses color in its examples.BP976left
proofsrequiredThe OEBP encourages any user uploading an example to provide a proof the example fits where they think it does.BP1125left
noproofsIt is very difficult to be sure where an example fits in this Bongard Problem; a user uploading an example does not need to have a proof the example fits where they think it does; if an error is found, the community will correct it later.BP1125right
left-unknowableIt is impossible to be sure an example fits left in this Bongard Problem. Just sort as left the examples that nobody has yet found to fit right.BP1124left
right-unknowableIt is impossible to be sure an example fits right in this Bongard Problem. Just sort as right the examples that nobody has yet found to fit left.BP1124right
left-narrowLeft examples are distinctive enough alone to communicate the answer; right examples are unnecessary.BP513left
right-narrowRight examples are distinctive enough alone to communicate the answer; left examples are unnecessary.BP514left
left-finiteA Bongard Problem with a finite number of possible examples fitting left.BP515left
right-finiteA Bongard Problem with a finite number of possible examples fitting right.BP516left
left-fullA Bongard Problem page that intends to collect ALL left examples.BP573left
right-fullA Bongard Problem page that intends to collect ALL right examples.BP574left
left-nullA Bongard Problem that would sort a blank panel on its left side.BP567left
right-nullA Bongard Problem that world sort a blank panel on its right side.BP567right
left-itA meta Bongard Problem that sorts the "it" Problem on its left side.BP1073left
right-itA meta Bongard Problem that sorts the "it" Problem on its right side.BP1073right
wellfoundedA meta Bongard Problem that contains no infinite chain of meta-Bongard Problems containing meta Bongard Problems . . .BP794right
feedbackA meta Bongard Problem that contains a chain of meta-Bongard Problems containing meta Bongard Problems . . . that eventually loops back to itself.BP1074left
ignoreimperfectionsA Bongard Problem with hand-drawn examples that may be slightly wrong.BP913right
perfectA Bongard Problem that does NOT have the typical slightly-wrong hand-drawings for examples; all subtle imperfections are relevant.BP913left
pixelperfectThe OEBP prefers for users to never submit images in which the pixellation is misleading.BP947left
infinitedetailImages are intended to be parsed as infinitely detailed structures.BP958left
infodenseEach example is tightly packed with information the solver has to unpack in order to solve the Bongard Problem.BP978left
assumesfamiliarityA Bongard Problem requiring the solver to go in with certain expectations for the solution to seem simple.BP1111left
structureA Bongard Problem with all examples featuring a specific multi-part structure commonly used on the OEBP, e.g. the Bongard Problem.BP789left
consistentsymbolsA Bongard Problem in which there is an intended consistent way to parse symbols shown in the examples.BP838left
collectiveA Bongard Problem in which there is no clear way to sort individual examples, but together many examples are able to communicate the idea.BP837left
finishedUsers should not submit any more examples to this Problem.BP504right
helpThe OEBP encourages users to upload examples that are designed to hint people toward the solution.BP930left
contributepairsThe OEBP encourages users to upload left and right examples in matching pairs.BP919left
instructionA keyword added to Bongard Problem pages to instruct OEBP users about what kinds of edits they should make to the page rather than to catalogue a property of the Bongard Problem.BP967right
sequenceA Bongard Problem about arbitrarily long sequences of objects.BP929left
fixedsequenceA Bongard Problem about sequences of objects of fixed length.BP929right
unorderedpairA Bongard Problem about comparing two objects such that the order of the objects does not matter.BP787right
orderedpairA Bongard Problem about comparing a first object with a second object.BP787left
unorderedtripletA Bongard Problem about comparing three objects such that the order of the objects does not matter.BP908right
orderedtripletA Bongard Problem about comparing a first object, a second object, and a third object.BP908left
timeA Bongard Problem that can change how it sorts examples over time. This probably means the Bongard Problem has cultural references.BP510left
invalidSomething that does not quite fit the definition of Bongard Problem but is interesting enough to keep in the database.BP522left
impossibleA Bongard Problem page for an idea that couldn't physically be made into a Bongard Problem.BP821left
experimentalA Bongard Problem that was created to push boundaries of what Bongard Problems are allowed to be.BP550left
traditionalA Bongard Problem featuring black and white images with a simple solution property.BP550right
funnyAn amusing Bongard Problem.BP1000left
blackwhiteinvariantBP556right
left-listableBP563left
bongardBP798left
presentationinvariantBP895right
right-listableBP940left
visualimaginationBP960left
inductivedefinitionBP1128left
finishedexamplesBP1142left
continuousBP1152right
discreteBP1152left
rulesBP1158left
right-couldbeBP1159right
left-couldbeBP1159left
viceversaBP1162left
problemkillerBP1170left
fixedgridBP1176right
gridBP1176left
miniworldsBP1180left
bothBP1188left
neitherBP1189left
preciseworldBP1190left
absolutepositionBP1195left
bordercontentBP1196left
ditheringBP1198left
stableworldBP1203right
unstableworldBP1203left
stabilityBP1204left
deformstableBP1205right
deformunstableBP1205left
dependenceBP1225left
seemslikeBP1231left
missingproofsBP1243left

Welcome | Solve | Browse | Lookup | Recent | Links | Register | Contact
Contribute | Keywords | Concepts | Worlds | Ambiguities | Transformations | Invalid Problems | Style Guide | Goals | Glossary